Downtown Benny's Pizza Menu

From a reviewer’s perspective, the menu at Downtown Benny's Pizza delivers a satisfying and well-rounded Italian-American experience that feels both familiar and thoughtfully extensive. The foundation of the menu starts strong with Create Your Own Pizza, offering options like Traditional Pizza, Grandma Pizza 16”, Sicilian Pizza, Cauliflower Pizza 12”, and Gluten Free Pizza 12”, which make it easy for diners to customize based on taste or dietary needs. For those who prefer signature combinations, the Specialty Pizza selection-including Margherita Pizza, Pesto Chicken Pizza, Benny's Special Pizza, Meat Lovers Pizza, and Hawaiian Pizza-highlights classic and crowd-pleasing flavors, while Traditional Pizza Slice is perfect for a quick bite. Value seekers will appreciate the X-Large Cheese Pizza Monday & Tuesday Special. Beyond pizza, the variety continues with appetizers such as Garlic Rolls, Garlic Bread, Cheesy Garlic Bread, French Fries, and Cheese Fries, along with comforting choices like Soup Of The Day. Fresh options are well represented through House Salad, Caesar Salad, Antipasto Salad, Tuna Salad Platter, and Chef's Salad. Hearty Italian staples appear in Cheese Calzone, Meat Calzone, Spinach Calzone, Vegetable Calzone, and Stromboli, as well as sandwiches like Turkey & Cheese Sub, Italian Combo Sub, Tuna & Cheese Sub, Gyro, and Chicken Caesar Wrap. The hot grinders-such as Chicken Parmigiana Grinder, Meatball Parmigiana Grinder, Eggplant Parmigiana Grinder, Italian Sausage Parmigiana Grinder, and House Philly Steak Grinder-add serious comfort food appeal. Dinner classics like Spaghetti With Marinara Sauce, Penne With Marinara Sauce, Penne A La Vodka, Penne Alfredo, and Uncle Willy's Lasagna round out the savory offerings, while the Kid's Menu and desserts like Cheesecake, Cannoli, Tiramisu, Zeppolis, and Chocolate Cake ensure something for everyone. With beverages, catering menus, and generous variety, the menu feels complete, approachable, and ideal for both casual meals and group gatherings.